Fact:
The medical examiner's conclusion that Chanelle
Pickett died of manual strangulation and suffocation did
not stand up in court.
Question:
Do we have a medical
examiner whose testimony doesn't stand up in court, or
do we have a medical examiner who doesn't care enough
about the lives of poor black transsexuals to do a
careful job on their behalf? Or is there simply no
medical testimony that can stand up against the power of
money?
Fact:
Members of the jury stated that the prosecution
did not do a good job of giving them the evidence they
needed to convict Palmer of murder or manslaughter.
Question:
They convicted him of an assault and battery
that led directly to Chanelle's death. How could they
not convict him of manslaughter, which was defined by
the judge as a death resulting from the actions of
another, including, for example, a heart attack directly
brought about by an altercation?
Fact:
The prosecution's argument that William Palmer
killed Chanelle Pickett "to shut her up" was not
convincing.
Question:
If the prosecution couldn't come
up with a more compelling case for first-degree murder,
why didn't it admit to the jury that 2nd degree murder
or manslaughter would be the appropriate conviction - or
at least a possible alternative - instead of sticking
with an argument it couldn't win?
Fact:
Chanelle Pickett lived and died as a woman.
Question:
Why does the media keep reporting on Chanelle
as a "he", if not to fuel anti-transgender sentiments
(and thereby violence) by an obvious show of disrespect?
Fact:
Palmer admits knowing that the bar where he met
Chanelle was a transsexual hangout, but claims that he
didn't know that Chanelle "was a man".
Question:
If he was so naïve, so what? He picked her up at a TS hangout
- wouldn't it be reasonable for her to assume that he
knew about her? Could it be that Palmer led her to
believe she had found a good man who truly liked her for
what she was - a rare thing in the difficult life of a
TS woman - only to cruelly reject her at a vulnerable
moment, then use his size advantage to put an end to her
inconvenient upset?
The Remember Chanelle Committee